Tribals, Not Hindu by Birth Dr. Tahir Mahmood's Brilliant Analysis, 20 January,1999


 

Are all the tribals of India Hindu by birth? ... A presumption to this effect underlies all that is being said and done in respect of the alleged conversions of the tribals to Christianity and the resulting wrath of Hindu militants against the Christians. If one has to rely on the Constitutional laws and the modern Hindu Code, ... the whole premises is incorrect and has no legs to stand.

The Constitution of India includes some special provisions for the "Scheduled Tribes", as it does for the "Scheduled Castes" ... The Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order 1950 said in so many words that a non-Hindu could never be a "Scheduled Caste" ... The Scheduled Caste law is, thus, clearly religion-based and its religious basis has generated abundant case law .... This

law has been clearly designed with the object of preventing low-caste Hindus, even if disgruntled with religion-based social inequalities, from converting to Christianity or Islam.

The law on Scheduled Tribes is, on the contrary, wholly free from religious shackles. The "No-non-Hindu please" clause ... has no parallel in the Constitution (Scheduled Tribes) Order 1950. Nor is there any judicial decision saying that all Scheduled Tribes.are born Hindus.

Any change of religion on the part of a member of a Scheduled Tribe does not legally alter his or her Scheduled Tribe status.

The Hindu Code of 1955-56 does not apply to Scheduled Tribes ... In respect of several tribal communities there have been judicial decisions specifically affirming that the four Hindu-law enactments of 1955-56 do not extend to the Scheduled Tribes.

The Census Reports of India do not treat the tribal communities as born Hindu. Appendix 'C' to the Census Report of 1991 gives details of "Sects/Beliefs/Religions  clubbed with . another religion". According to this Annexure, no tribal community has been clubbed with the followers of the Hindu religion in the Report ... The head of "Other Religions and Persuasions" is detailed in Appendix 'A' to the Report (which) about sixty tribal religions are separately specified .... This Appendix also includes a residuary head of "Tribal Religion" -- and, then, an additional head of "Unclassified" Religions and Persuasions", which also must be inclusive of many smaller tribes ...

Indian law as a whole as it stands now, thus, does not recognise the claim that all tribals of India are born Hindus. They are born into their own peculiar religions ..

Like all other Indians they do have a right to embrace any other religion of their choice ... Hindu religious preachers can, thus, lawfully offer their religion to the tribals. So can the Christians, Muslims, Buddhists and followers of all other major religions ... peacefully and strictly within legal parameters. The tribals must, then, be allowed to have their pick. They must, of course, also be allowed to stick to their own ... original faiths, if they so choose ...

 

 

 

 

 

 

Shahabuddin's Letter to Dr. Tahir Mahmood, 25 January, 1999

Thank you for your letter No. CH/97/NCM dated 22 January, 1999 and the annexures thereto, particularly for your Statement of 20.1.1999 on the ST's.

The point you have been made about the tribals not being Hindu by birth is valid but the 1991 Census figures indicate a total tribal population of 67.76 million while only 3.68 million persons fall in the last 2 categories 'Other Religious and Persuasions" and "Religion not stated". Even if we assume all of them to be tribals, it would mean that only 5.44 of the tribals have not

embraced one of the 6 established religions. Since the total Christian population in the country was 19,640,284 only assuming 50% to be tribals, it follows that over 54.25 million tribals are 'officially' Hindu by religion.

The normal practice in the census operation has been that unless a person declares himself to be the follower of one of the other 5 established religion, he is categorised as a Hindu (barring a few like Parsis or Bahais etc.). Thus the Hindus have been the beneficiaries of the Census. Unless there is mass awakening among the tribals, they are not likely to assert their constitutional right of being recorded in Census as they are.

You may like to ask the Registrar General of India for the religion-wise break-up of the tribal population in 1991, since there are at least some who follow one of the 5 minority religions.





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives