What does the Samajwadi Party chief do as he finds the ground shifting beneath his feet? He releases that familiar creature - the genie of reservations. His party, he announces, will reserve jobs and seats in educational institutions and legislatures for Muslims if voted to power.
The move insults the intelligence of the supposed beneficiaries of Mulayam Singh's largesse, because the Constitution does not allow for religion-based reservations and it is very unlikely that the Samajwadi Party can alter this reality. Even more importantly, it undermines the very principles that undergird reservations. The efficacy of any move that institutionalises positive discrimination hinges
Shahabuddin's Scheme of Reservation Letter to The Nation & the World, 18 Oct., 99
While many statements by Ishrat Husain and Jaseem H. Siddiqui in their article on Reservation (October 1, 1999) are no more than mere repetitions of the old arguments against the concept of reservation, yet some apprehensions expressed by them against the excesses of reservation policy are indeed real and need to be addressed by those who believe in reservation as a tool of social engineering to level existing social, economic and political disparities among various sections of our people.
Personally, I have been long suggesting that :-
a) The quota for any backward group should be proportionate not only to its population but also to its level of backwardness as compared to the national/state average.
b) Any social group - identifiable by religion, caste, race, language and self-conscious - has a backward section so that the group - however 'forward' as a whole deserves a small quota.
c) A group quota should primarily benefit the backward sections of the group in terms of families and candidates. This implies that the cut-off line of creamy layer should be realistically drawn and strictly applied to bar those above the line from the benefit of reservation.
d) Reservation should apply to all services/cadres at the point of entry but not to successive promotions but the promotion should be by seniority-cum-fitness and not by merit, since comparative merit cannot be accurately determined and subjective factors come into play when CR's are written and interviews are conducted.
However, objective examinations may be prescribed to determine fitness.
e) There should be a review of the quota every 10 years. As backwardness recedes, the quota will decrease.
The above scheme which is but a sketch will mean that while all social groups will benefit from reservation, there shall always remain a common pool which will go on increasing in size as quotas recede with development. This scheme has no place for an arbitrary limit of 50%.
Reservation and education must go together. In fact backward groups can take advantage of reservation when they throw up candidates with minimum qualification. The S.C. has wisely barred erosion of minimum qualification for admission to medical or technical institutions. I think there should no age relaxation either except in terms of equal number of chances immediately after obtaining the minimum academic qualification.
So long as there is socio-economic inequality not only among individuals but also among identifiable and self-conscious groups, there are only two convergent approaches towards equality - universal education and universal reservation. There can be no equality among unequals. It is time to correlate the demand for inter-group justice with the need for efficient management of the state, before the state blows up and disintegrates in the struggle between the haves and the have not on it benefitting the truly marginalised. Therefore, while it is only right that Dalits, tribals and backward castes are the recipients of ... reservations given the discrimination they have faced over the centuries, religious categories are, by their very nature, too broad to be thus privileged.
While a case can be made for backward sections among minorities being given reservations, it would be a gross travesty of justice for the more prosperous to benefit in this manner just by virtue of being part of a minority ...
Sadly ... every major party in these elections has attempted to woo significant sections by employing similar strategies ... Such competitive patronage ... will only result in more and more groups clamouring for similar recognition. But what do the politicians care? Their sights are set on the immediate gains to be had from shotgun marriages to electorally powerful groups ...