Supreme Court on Scope of Reservation in Professional Education


 

Preeti Srivastava and another, Petitioners v. State of Madhya Pradesh and others, Respondents and other cases.

A.S. ANAND, CJI, S.B. MAJMUDAR, SUJATA V. MANOHAR, K. VENKATASWAMI & V.N. KHARE, JJ.

Constitution of India, Article 16(4) Reservation in service - Is a transitory measure -Once backward class secure adequate representation in services - Reservation will not be required.

Article 15(4) - Protective discrimination in favour of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes - Policies and programmes of protective discrimination - To be designed and pursued in a manner to build an egalitarian non-discriminating society - Interests of society as a whole cannot be ignored while testing reasonableness of programmes.

Articles 226, 15 - Education - Medical College - Admission - Speciality and super speciality courses - Special provisions for SC and ST -Cannot be made for super speciality courses -provision for speciality courses should be minimum.

... Post-graduate medical course – Common entrance examination - Prescribing of minimum qualifying marks - Is necessary since it is not a mere screening test.

... Fixing of lower qualifying marks for SC, ST - Medical Council to decide - Disparity between marks fixed for reserved and general candidates should not be big.

State cannot prescribe criteria which adversely affect standard of higher education laid down by Union of India - Regulation framed by Medical Council are binding – State Government cannot make rules which impinge upon these Regulations - Admission criteria has a direct impact on standard of education. (Source: AIR 1999 Supreme Çourt 2894)





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives