Preeti Srivastava and another, Petitioners v. State of Madhya Pradesh and others, Respondents and other cases.
A.S. ANAND, CJI, S.B. MAJMUDAR, SUJATA V. MANOHAR, K. VENKATASWAMI & V.N. KHARE, JJ.
Constitution of India, Article 16(4) Reservation in service - Is a transitory measure -Once backward class secure adequate representation in services - Reservation will not be required.
Article 15(4) - Protective discrimination in favour of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes - Policies and programmes of protective discrimination - To be designed and pursued in a manner to build an egalitarian non-discriminating society - Interests of society as a whole cannot be ignored while testing reasonableness of programmes.
Articles 226, 15 - Education - Medical College - Admission - Speciality and super speciality courses - Special provisions for SC and ST -Cannot be made for super speciality courses -provision for speciality courses should be minimum.
... Post-graduate medical course – Common entrance examination - Prescribing of minimum qualifying marks - Is necessary since it is not a mere screening test.
... Fixing of lower qualifying marks for SC, ST - Medical Council to decide - Disparity between marks fixed for reserved and general candidates should not be big.
State cannot prescribe criteria which adversely affect standard of higher education laid down by Union of India - Regulation framed by Medical Council are binding – State Government cannot make rules which impinge upon these Regulations - Admission criteria has a direct impact on standard of education. (Source: AIR 1999 Supreme Çourt 2894)