Shahabuddin's Letters to PM Vajpayee On Renaming Mughal Sarai, 17 February, 1999


 

 

The UP Chief Minister Kalyan Singh has announced that his Government has decided to change the name of Mughalsarai to Deen Dayal Upadhyay Nagar.

There can be no objection to the construction of a suitable memorial even the establishment of an academic institution in Mughalsarai to commemorate his brutal killing in Mughalsarai in 1968 but the had no particular association with his life and work and had not been his Karnabhoomi. On the other hand, Mughalsarai is a historic name.

In principle, any change of the name of a place or site is not right. In this case, the proposal reeks of Muslim phobia, no more, no less.

I do not see why your Government should be a party to an act of political revenge which would merely add to the felt alienation of the Muslim community.

I, therefore, request you that your Government should reject the proposal, if and when it is formally submitted by the State Government in the interest of national integration,

 On Renaming Schemes, 19 March, 1999

According to a press report, the PMO has undertaken an exercise for renaming schemes and institutions named after individuals. There have also been reports from various BJP-ruled States about proposal to rename places and roads.

Renaming is a symbolic act, devoid of substance, Launching development and welfare schemes, establishing new institutions, founding towns and building roads is the duty of all governments. Naming them is an associated prerogative, according to its light. But renaming existing schemes, institutions, towns and roads is not only an empty gesture, but ineffective and futile. The Congress Government renamed Connaught Place as Rajiv Chowk. It is still called Connaught Place.

Needless to add that such gestures constitute an unedifying comment on the ability of the government in power to do anything better than its predecessor! And it can set into motion a chain of renaming with every ideological change in the government.

 I, therefore, request you to stop this exercise and set a healthy precedent by not naming new or renaming old institutions after contemporary personalities, living or dead.

However, I may add in all fairness that if a new scheme is launched which goes beyond and 'absorbs' and substitute the existing scheme, there is a case for giving it a new name.

 





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives