I have read with dismay your statement in the Indian Express (23 October, 1999) that the Constitution stands in the way of reservation on the basis of religion.
Humbly, I beg to disagree with your view.
Article 14 of the Constitution grants equality before the law and equal protection of the law to all persons. Article 15(1) bars discrimination by the State against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of them. Thus it treats religion, race and caste equally. The word 'only' is the key to its understanding. That is why when any of the facts mentioned above are complimented with 'social or educational backwardness', deliberate discrimination by the State is permitted under Article 16(4) to make 'any special provision for their advancement'.
The term Class merely stands for classification and a backward Class is an identifiable social group which is objectively backward (as determined by an appropriate authority armed with appropriate criteria). It may equally mean a group identified by caste, religion, race or even place of birth (e.g. Bihari labour or Assam tea plantation).
Even the S.C. in Inder Sawheny case has clearly hinted at validity of classification based on religion. That the Muslim Indians, 50 years after independence, constitute a Backward Class is well-established. Indeed the Muslim community, as such, has been declared a Backward Class in Kerala, Karnataka, Manipur and even Tamilnadu. Obviously the Constitution cannot have different meanings in different States!
I would, therefore, request you to reconsider your view on the subject.
As far as the various occupational groups among Muslims (similar to those among the Hindu OBCs) are concerned, most of them are indeed covered by the Mandal Lists. However, you will appreciate that in a common list, they stand little charm of getting equitable benefits in competition with relatively more advanced and politically powerful groups like Yadavas, Kurmis, Koeris etc. So even under the existing dispensation, they deserve a separate quota of at least 4.2 per cent.