Sangh Parivar: Tax Evasion or Tax Holiday


 

For over a decade now, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) has been able to amass huge amounts of money in India and seek tax exemption because it has been classified as a charitable trust. This categorisation has been questioned by income tax authorities as it is violative of income tax laws which clearly disqualify any trust "established for the benefit of any particular religious community or caste". Furthermore, the law also states that at least 75 per cent of the income accumulated should be utilised for charitable purposes. But none of the VHP's income and expenditure statements submitted to the Income Tax department reflects this. Besides, six of its affiliates have also been accorded this recognition.

The VHP has come into focus because of a proposed amendment to Sections 11 and 12 in the budget session - the relevant sections of the Income Tax Act which accords them this classification, as a smart ploy to legitimise the VHP's money-collection operations ..

The proposed amendment allows the charitable status to continue even if 5 per cent of the total receipts is spent for religious purposes ..

For the record, the VHP collects about Rs. 2 crores a year. But income tax officials point out that the official figures do not reflect the monies collected by the organisation both from within and outside the country. Guesstimates have it that this could run into hundreds of crores. For instance, the VHP's balance-sheet for the year ending March 31, 1998 ... shows that 24 prants (zones) were unaudited. Of a reported income of Rs.2.7 crores, it claims to have disbursed Rs. 1.52 crore as 'grants' but there are no annexures to state what organisations received these grants or where they are located. The only charitable work, "Help to Poor" as listed in the balance-sheer, is Rs. 0,101. In the previous year, no such help was rendered.

According to Swami Swaroopanand Saraswati, Shankaracharya of Dwaraka Jyotipeeth, the VHP has received hundreds of crores of rupees as donation for the construction of the Ram temple at Ayodhya. He had written to Vishnu Hari Dalmia, the VHP President, as far back as 1990, alleging misuse of these funds. He still reiterates the charge: "The VHP has been fooling the people. I know that it has collected money from NRIs.

People have told me that they donated large sums of money. But this has not been used for the mandir. So someone has to investigate and find out where all the money has gone".

The money-raking methods of the VHP and its affiliates, both within the country and abroad have always been shrouded in controversy. During the shilanyas pujas in 1990, the VHP had collected, according to its own admission, Rs.8.29 crore from devotees. However, unofficial figures put it at hundreds of crores. At the Allahabad Sant Sammelan held in late January the next year, it claimed to have spent Rs.1.63 crore of the sum on the pujas and the foundation stone-laying ceremony at Ayodhya ..

That there is friction within the organisation is evident ... The books of the Sri Ram Janambhoomi Nyas, a sister body of the VHP, have also run into severe problems but no action has been initiated. In 1990, it filed income tax returns which showed a staggering Rs.1.20 crore

deficit. "Under the IT Act, a charitable trust enjoying tax exemption benefits should not spend more than it earns, except in unforeseen circumstances which threatened its existence," says a tax official. The Nyas collected a total of Rs.8.48 lakh through coupons and receipts. However, it spent Rs.31 lakh towards the cost of paper and printing these coupons alone and an additional Rs.1.69 lakh for distributing them in the country! In other words, the Nyas spent over Rs.32.69

lakh to earn Rs. 8.48 lakh.

The only time the accounts were sought to be scrutinised was in March 1990, when an income tax officer, Vishv Bandhu Gupta ... summoned the VHP's top brass, but he was promptly shunted out.

In 1988, the VHP had applied for Foreign Contribution Regulation Act status but that was shot down by the Reserve Bank of India. However, some of its affiliates like the Bharat Kalyan Pratishthan have been receiving foreign funds for the last four years ...

"Constructing a temple or converting Christians does not by any stretch of imagination construe charitable or secular acts," says a senior revenue department official.

Many have expressed surprise over the legal cover the VHP enjoys ...

Also, in the course of investigations into the hawala scam, the CBI and enforcement agencies made a startling discovery. The overseas sister organisations of the VHP had routed money to the parent organisation through a London-based hawala operator, Mohini Jain. She was one of the four channels through which S.K. Jain and brothers received money in India for further disbursals. But nothing came of the case and it met with a quiet burial ...

Enforcement officials point out that a lot of illegal money was brought in through the vostro account during the securities scam. Computronics Private Ltd., a Mumbai firm owned by Singhal's nephew, was involved ...

"But the matter wasn't pursued actively", says an Enforcement official ... By all accounts, a crackdown on the VHP seems unlikely. Income tax officials point out that a VHP-friendly BJP cannot be expected to act when even the United Front and the Congress government had failed to examine its accounts ... (Source: The Outlook, 22 March, 1999)





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives