Readings on Minorities Perspectives and Documents, Vol. I & Il by Iqbal Ansari Review by D.P. Sathe


 

These two volumes besides providing the reader with important international documents on minorities rights contain thought-provoking articles on the subject by eminent persons ... The second volume contains documents evidencing various important events in India that took place during the national movement for independence, debates in the Constituent Assembly of India and provisions of the Indian Constitution containing rights of the minorities.

What are minorities? We do not include in the definition of minorities the political dissenters, who also might be a minority. In a democracy, they get their right to dissent through the guarantee of freedom of speech and expression. A minority is described by Fawcett as "a group in a country which possesses and has a common will, however, conditioned - to preserve certain habits and patterns of life and behaviour which may be ethnic, cultural, linguistic or religious, or a combination of them, and which characterize it as a group. Further, such a group may be politically dominant or non-document" (p.3, Vol. I). Usually a minority group is

(a) numerically smaller than the majority;

(b) has a distinct identity and is

(c) powerless as compared to the majority.

According to Fawcett, minority is a non-dominant group with a distinct ethnic, cultural or linguistic identity ... A minority needs to be protected because of its  powerlessness vis-à-vis the dominant ethnic, religious group. Such a minority requires not only the equal protection of law ... but the right to preserve its distinct identity. Separatism is different from separateness. In a plural nationalism, there are vertical as well as horizontal federalisms.

Where regions want to retain their identity and yet be part of the national mainstream, they organise a federal government in which the units retain powers and give some power to the Centre. Where various distinct religious, ethnic or linguistic groups want to retain their identities, they organise vertical federalism in which minorities are guaranteed the right to equal protection and also the right to their distinct identities, culture and traditions.

Migration and minorities have always had a cause and effect relationship ...

Every country is bound to have a minority or minorities. The editor rightly says that the "Mazzinian view of culturally homogeneous nation-state has really never existed in any part of the world." (xi). The editor cautions the minorities against nurturing separatist feelings and majorities against adopting assimilationists strategies,  intolerance and hegemony. Both have to be avoided.

"Pluralism in togetherness" would be the ideal to be shared by the majorities and the minorities. The editor therefore observes that what was required was a redefinition of the State, as a multi-ethnic State (xx)…

Two ways of dealing with minority problems are: (1) separation and (2) integration. The right of self-determination is usually conceded where a people are living under a colonial or foreign rule and the desire for separation is intense. Since the liberation of the former colonies after the Second World War, demands for separation from parts of the liberated colonies surfaced which threatened their disintegration. The international community has not encouraged such demands unless living together was impossible.

The United Nations in its declaration on the granting of Independence to colonial countries and people stated that "any attempt aimed at the partial or total disruption of the national unity and territorial integrity of a country is incompatible with the U.N. Charter." (p.4). It has been held that the imperatives of national building must take priority over many of the rights formally attributed to ethnic minorities. (23). A distinction is made between a people, however, small in number or territory, deemed capable of independence and U.N. membership and nationalities or minorities living within a larger country.

Self-determination is accorded to the first but not necessarily to the others (p.24). Minorities which cannot separate have to live within the majority. A pluralistic state would try its best to create conditions for harmonious co-existenge, Claire Palley discusses various rights guaranteed to the minorities through constitutional provisions and arrangements. He points out federalism, proportional representation, administrative decentralisation as possible devices of integrating the minorities within the mainstream without obliterating their distinct identity. Francesco Copotorti discusses the protection of minorities under various multilateral agreements.

In the second volume, we have articles on the Indian experience, the most notable among them being by the editor himself and by Prof. Rajni Kothari and Justice V.M. Tarkunde, Ansari points out under what circumstances the Muslim members after partition voluntarily gave up the demand for separate electorates. The first past the post system has resulted in the alienation of all minorities. If not separate electorates, we should at least go in for proportional representation. Such electoral reform is overdue. It will reduce the power of those who can win elections by securing a minimum number of votes and ensure that one who gets elected has secured not less than 50% of the votes.

Gandhi's insistence that separate electorates for the depressed classes would break the unity of Hindu society might have been consistent with his Hindu nationalism. But we have seen that reserved seats have killed the depressed classes movement and made it leaderless. Why did Gandhi not object to separate electorates for Muslims? Ansari observes that Gandhi and Congress also thought in  terms of a majoritarian nationalism and not pluralistic nationalism. Was there not a subtle desire to assimilate the minorities within Hindu nationalism? Their Hindu nationalism, unlike that of the BJP, was not negative as being against somebody but did it not smell of cultural hegemony?

Tarkunde analyses the origin of collectivism which is the root cause of communalism. He points out that communalism of the majority takes the form of nationalism ... and therefore accepted as legitimate.

Tarkunde rightly says that communalism is an internal enemy residing in the human mind and it is far more difficult to eradicate it than an external enemy like an autocratic ruler (p.50 vol.2) ... Tarkunde examines the policies and practices of the BJP and other Hindutva groups and shows how their majoritarian politics could harm the country and pollute the democratic process .. S.A. Abedi writes an options for Muslim minorities in plural societies.

These volumes would doubtless be good acquisitions for a library and also for serious students of human rights. [Dr. S.P. Sathe is the Honorary Director, Institute of Advanced Legal Studies, Pune] (Source: The Freedom First, January-March, 1998)





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives