I sincerely thank you for your letter of 19 October, 1999 which I received only yesterday.
I am glad that you have, like a good friend, frankly asked some questions and made some observations.
The name Muslim India has no separatist connotation. I am a Muslim Indian, i.e. basically an Indian who happens to be a Muslim by faith. Collectively Muslim Indians form a conscious and identifiable social group and interact with the other segments of the larger Indian society and polity. This Journal restricts itself to recording and compiling these interactions. In fact, secular ideology, in the multi-religious context of our country, has an essential element - the protection of the constitutional and legal rights of the religious minorities and the promotion of their legitimate interests and aspirations.
I admire and yet oppose the RSS and all the organisations like the VHP associated with it, for only one reason their object and purpose is to Hinduise India – its culture, society and polity. India to me is larger than Hinduism. Though Hinduism is the foundation on which Indian culture stands, it is not the same as Hindu culture. Nor is Indian culture static. It is as dynamic as Gangaji. It is not today what it was in the Gupta Age; nor will it be tomorrow what it is today.
All-religions contribute to the making of culture. So there is a Hindu culture and a Muslim culture and many other cultures, but all come together in harmony to make up what is Indian Culture. Religion cannot be restricted to mode of worship only, as you say, it affects our whole being and we live it.
I do not think the religious minorities wish to 'break religious boundaries'. Hinduism has a history of religious assimilation. Today no religious group is prepared to be absorbed, to be assimilated, to be submerged. What we should aim at is not to erase the boundaries but make them friendly and interactive, so that each group maintains its identity, respects, and learns from, the others, avoids conflicts and clashes and contributes to the pattern of peaceful, harmonious co-existence, as the co-citizens of a common state and as co-participants in the making and running of the Indian polity, society and economy.
The wold is moving towards multi-ethnicity. The 'melting pot' is out; the 'mosaic' is in. I firmly believe in India's destiny as a model for the future - a multi-ethnic society at peace with itself, tolerant, progressive and dynamic.
This is my dream. I pray I live to see it realised.