Chandan Mitra
Even as Mr. Atal Bihari Vajpayee celebrates his first year in office with a quiet sense of satisfaction, he must ponder - where does he go from here ?... Contrary to the doomsday prophets, the Prime Minister seems set on course to lead India into the next millennium and, probably, further on.
That is why he must ask himself about his own agenda in the months and years to come.
... The track has not been easy to locate, given the layers and layers of political slush blocking the view. The coming months call for cleaning up the act so that the direction is clearly revealed ... Periodic middle class accolades cannot hide the reality that the poor are feeling increasingly alienated ... The BJP is still widely perceived as a party that favours the relatively affluent. For some years, the umbrella ideology of Hindutva had blurred the schisms. But now that Hindutva has lost its cutting edge and can no longer be electorally sold to the majority ...
Greater polarisation at this stage can only help the Congress which remains comfortably ahead of the BJP in terms of the all-India vote percentage. With the so-called Third Force hurtling towards self-destruction, the BJP's main political focus would have to be on refining the art of polarisation-management.
... Vajpayee's most arduous, long-term task is to re-ignite a sense of national pride. He has taken some significant steps ... However, national self-esteem appears to have hit its nadir in the last year. A bumbling Government, unable to control its allies, its lunatic fringe running riot on cricket pitches, outside cinema halls and inside Gujarat's sleepy hamlets, a "roll-back" economy in the doldrums - all combined to make a very unpretty picture ... Vajpayee cannot control that, but what he can do is generate that "feel-good" sentiment by being decisive, emphasising the economy and deftly managing coalition politics. As he crosses an important landmark in his long public life ... he himself; he must be the Vajpayee India wants to see. Source: The Pioneer, 19 March, 1999)
Dileep Padgaonkar
... The (Vajpayee) Government's woes are far from over ... Taken together they could yet cut short the life span of the country's first truly non-Congress governance. Still, Vajpayee's star rating is unimpaired ...
Given time to fulfil its term on these lines, and only along these sensible lines, the Vajpayee government may well achieve what the other formations possibly can't in equal measure; durable peace with China and Pakistan, a fair deal on non-proliferation, a critical impetus to economic reforms and reconciliation between the two largest religious groups in the country. The Congress and the other non-BJP opposition parties can ignore this prospect - which is eminently in the larger national interest - only at considerable peril to themselves. (Source: The Times of India, 20 March, 1999
Ishan Joshi
... For a leader whose well-publicised "differences" with his party are legion, stumbling into government accentuated this divide. But he held the Pokhran tests within the first 100 days ... one thing on which he, his party and the Sangh were in accord ... That done, Vajpayee stuck doggedly - almost desperately - to the national agenda for governance while paying lip-service to the BJP hardliners' more controversial agenda ... By the time a section of the BJP and the RSS ... realised that Vajpayee was ... disinterested in (their Agenda), the ruling coalition had bonded together strongly enough withstand the grumbles. ..
Vajpayee tried to ... convert the BJP into a "party of governance". But the phrase may mean different things ... For Vajpayee, it signifies a middle-of-the-road government; conservative yet liberal, right of centre but with a human face. The emphasis is on initiatives on infrastructure, yet continuing with the liberalisation regime. Exploding the nuclear bomb, but taking the bus to Lahore. In short, "governance sans ideology" ... A pre- Indira Congress, without the corruption and the dynasty, offers an aide. Not too many takers, though.
Vajpayee rolled with the punches. The rout in the assembly elections and the losses in the by-elections were accepted with good grace. But it also allowed Vajpayee to nudge the BJP down a moderate path, focussing on issues of governance rather than those of identity. And he got more assertive with the Sangh and difficult allies. Vajpayee saw the political grouping at the heart of the coalition as the nucleus of a long-term alternative to the Congress. As the BJP is yet to make it big in the south and east, alliances will prove crucial again, is the argument. Others feel that running a coalition should teach the BJP a lesson: better alone in Opposition than in power "like this". The results of the nine states going to the polls in end, 1999 and early 2000 will make this decision for the BJP.
Vajpayee faces a three-pronged problem: the Congress will at some point attempt to force a mid-term poll or provide an alternative government. As he shows signs of consolidating, alarm bells, have begun to ring in opposition ranks. Secondly, those 'moderates' who think like him in the BJP ... are in the doghouse. And the shenanigans of some of his closest allies have provided his most embarrassing moments. His home minister literally chased away the Haryana Lok Dal that was supporting the coalition. The dismissal of naval chief Vishnu Bhagwat is descending into a brawl between ... George Fernandes and the sacked admiral. And nobody has yet contradicted Mohan Guruswamy's allegations against Vajpayee and his family. Despite their occasional vote of confidence in Vajpayee himself, allies frequently lambast his government. Even ... in Bihar ... the hard political reality is that he has had to eat crow twice. This could cost him: already half the Samata Party MLAs have joined Laloo.
Vajpayee, the consummate orator ... is ironically, not a great communicator in smaller groups ... The role of the elder who takes a decision after having consulted everybody. That is where the PMO comes in. Anticipating discontent from his party, he operates with the help of only a handful of trusted aides ... a few BJP moderates ... and a couple of key allies ... All other cabinet members, except Advani, are just that; ministers who are expected to perform. That he is a wily practitioner of realpolitik as well is sometimes lost on people ... (Source: The Outlook, 29 March, 1999)