I- Educational and Economic Development of Minorities
Finding that necessary action to implement the requirements of Article 30 of the Constitution in respect of the educational rights of the minorities was being often withheld by the Government offices believing that "a Special Bench of the Supreme Court is reconsidering the law on this subject", the Chairman prepared and released an Explanatory Note, on 7h April 1999, pointing out the following points:
(i) The Special Bench of the Court constituted in January 1997 had only part-heard the matter till 31" March 1997 and had not passed any interim order. Then, in July 1997 the Bench stood dissolved and has not since been re-constituted.
(ii) Later, on 7 September 1998, in the case of N. Ammad v. Emjay School, reported at JT 1998 (6) SC211, the Supreme Court has emphatically held that the established law on the minorities' educational rights, as settled long before 1997, remains fully in force.
Recommendation
It is recommended that these facts be given due recognition and no action in respect of any Minority educational institutions be withheld.
Il - Working of NMDFC: NCM Suggestions
Under the directions of the Commission, its Secretary Mrs. Lina Chakrabarti held a meeting with the Managing Director of the National Minorities Development and Finance Corporation (NMDFC) on 11 May. The purpose was to sort out the problems faced by the minorities in all parts of the country, brought to the notice of the Commission, in taking benefits of the NMDFC-Schemes and in dealing with its State Channelizing Agencies. After the action was reported to and approved by the full Commission at its meeting held on 26t June, a number of suggests made by the Commission to improve the working of the NMDFC were conveyed to its Managing Director.
Recommendation
The Commission recommenus an early comprehensive review of the working of NMDFC and its SCAs by an Experts Committee.
IlI - Proposals for Christian Law Reform
During 1997-98 the Commission had taken another important exercise - that of evolving necessary consensus among the various groups and sects of the Christians on the issue of the reform of their personal law now long overdue. Full details of this exercise will be found in the Commission's Annual Report for 1997-98.
In July 1999 the Law Ministry prepared a fresh Christian Family Laws (Amendment) Bill and the Government proposed to enforce it by an Ordinance (as the Lok Sabha then stood dissolved). The proposal was referred to the Commission and, on a cursory glance, it was found that the four draft-bills approved by the Commission in 1997 with the consent of various groups of the community had been largely deviated from in the Law Ministry's proposals. The extent of these deviations in the Government's proposals from the Draft-Bills of 1997 approved by the Commission and their justification is being examined by the Commission.
In the Commission's opinion, however, it was quite unnecessary to enforce the official proposals by means of an Ordinance, as the new Lok Sabha was expected to be in position shortly. This view of the Commission was immediately conveyed to the Government through letters written by the Commission's Secretariat to the SJE Ministry and by the Chairman himself to the Union Law Minister Ram Jethmalani.
Recommendation
The Commission urges the Government to have the Law Ministry's proposals revised in the light of the Draft-Bills sent by the Commission.
IV - Origin and Causes of Anti-Christian Violence
A well-known political leader made a press-statement on 25 September saying that the country was witnessing anti-Christian violence for the first time and that it was due to recent rise to particular political parties and leaders. As the statement was widely reported in the National media, the NCM Chairman examined it in depth and issued a clarification pointing out that:
"The atrocities against the Christians are neither an entirely novel phenomenon nor can they be attributed to the rise of particular political parties or leaders. The Minorities Commission, set up 21 years ago, had to deal with complaints of anti-Christian violence from the very beginning.
The Annual Report of the Commission for 1997 refers to complaints of 'Atrocities on Christians in Arunachal Pradesh and Bihar'. About a decade later the Commission had received similar complaints from Bhopal, Bhubaneswar and Bombay, details of which are found in its Annual Report for 1988-89. In 1997 the present Commission had inquired into a barbaric incident of anti-Christian violence in the Dumka township of Bihar.
The root-causes of all such communal tensions lie in the failure of the Indian society to fully absorb the Constitutional ideas of equality of citizens and their right to religious freedom, and not in the rise of any party or leader on the political horizon.
Recommendation
It is recommended that the Central and State Governments should take some concrete steps to educate the masses and make them fully conscious of the citizen's equality and equal civil and legal rights irrespective of their religion and creed.
V - Appeal for Enhanced Minority Presence in Legislatures
As its meeting held on 29t June 1999 the Commission decided to recommend to all the major political parties that they should try to enhance the representation of Minorities in Parliament and State Legislatures so as to ensure about a hundred seats in it for persons belonging to Various Minorities communities ... The Chairman later conveyed this recommendation to the heads of all the major political parties ... Text of the Chairman's letter is reproduced below:
"The UN Declaration on the Rights of Minorities 1992 speaks of the right of the Minorities in every country lo effectively participate in the national decision-making processes. And the Constitution of India guarantees equality of state a id opportunity to all the citizens of the gountry. B .. tne national and international laws, thus, dearly provide for a fair share of the minorities in the Hovernance of the countries. We in the Commission have a eonvinced opinion that the first and foremost condition of an effective empowerment of the minorities in India, the need fo, which is often talked about by all and sundry, is to ensure them adequate participation in the affairs of the nation.
Unfortunately, the presence of the minorities in Parliament has ever since 1950 been quite disproportionate to their actual population in the country. The demand for reservation for minorities, raised from certain quarters, is confused with the so-called 'communal representation' and is opposed generally on the presumption that a minority-community candidate will represent only the concerned minority, which itself is prima facie wrong. We are, however, not talking of either 'communal representation' or even a formal reservation.
We only want that the minorities should be given a fair share, more or less proportionate to their population, in terms of seats in the legislatures - where they will, of course, represent the entire constituencies and not particular communities. And, in our opinion, this is to be achieved by an inform political - and not by a formal legal -process.
We, therefore, recommend that all political parties should, at the time of allotment of tickets for election to Parliament and State Assemblies, ensure the minorities of the country a reasonable presence in both the national and the State-level legislative bodies, proportionate to their population as far as possible. The minority population in the country according to the latest Census Reports is 18.59%. Going by this percentage, the minority should have over a hundred seats in Parliament. We do, therefore, especially recommend that all political parties should try to ensure about a 100 seats for the Minorities in the next Lok Sabha.
VI - Corporation Status for Gujarat Minorities Board
The Gujarat Minorities Board functioning since 1981 had been elevated to the status of a Corporation by the previous State Government, but the implementation of the decision was withheld by the present Government. On the recommendation of the NCM the State Government has now finally given it the status of a Corporation.