1. Strengthening Human Rights Mechanisms
The Indian government must. repeal its reservations (on Article 5a and 16.1) to the International Convention on All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), and take the steps required by the Convention to eliminate discrimination against women, while respecting the rights of the Muslim community to its identity in conformity with Article 1.1 of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Persons belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities.
"States shall protect the existence and the national or ethnic, cultural, religious and linguistic identity of minorities, and shall encourage conditions for the promotion of that identity"
The government must honour its commitment to CEDAW, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
At a national level, the central government should ensure that State Minority Commissions are not disbanded or subsumed under other bodies. Minority Commissions should be allowed independent functioning. All individuals and parties who are guilty of human rights abuses during communal riots must be indicted and prosecuted.
2.Reform and Constitutional Provisions Reform in Muslim personal law based on the needs of Muslim women, on the principles of equal rights and which is consistent with international human rights standards, is an urgent necessity and requires the attention of the Muslim community.
Concurrently, the Indian government should adhere to international human rights standards and its own constitutional provisions safeguarding the interests of women citizens and, in accordance with Article 14 of the Indian Constitution, 'not deny any person equality before the law or the equal protection of the laws within the territory of India'.
Neither of the above undertakings need compromise the religious identity of the Muslim community nor their Indian nationality.
3. Self-Empowerment
It is crucial for members of Muslim communities especially Muslim women - to debate among themselves the reasons and solutions for their poor educational and employment status, their precarious economic situation, as well as the need for legal reform and greater political participation, and the possibilities of overcoming patriarchal structures within their own communities.
Muslim women need to participate in the contemporary debate on Islam and women's rights and to build cooperation and synergy between genders and between communities to secure their empowerment.
In a context where the Shari'a is used to justify the denial of rights and freedoms to Muslim women, Indian Muslim women need to reclaim their right to religious knowledge, enter into the discourse on the Shari'a and challenge their historic marginalization from religious knowledge and its discriminatory interpretations
4. Improving the Economic Status of Muslims
State agencies should actively develop and implement policies geared towards improving the socio-economic status of Muslim women and the Muslim community generally to ensure their full participation in public life as Indian citizens.
Such measures could include central government (collaboratively with state governments) implementation of loan schemes to facilitate the setting up of small businesses or skill training for Muslims; and the implementation of schemes for Muslim girls' and women's education in both rural and urban areas. This should be in conjunction with socio-economic measures so that Muslim women, particularly in urban areas (where illiteracy levels are high), can enjoy such economic benefits.
Shahabuddin's Letter to Minority Rights Group, UK, 7 April, 1999
Thank you for your letter of March 1999 and for a copy of your valuable report on "Muslim Women in India".
While I endorse the factual findings about the status of the Muslim Indian women, I do not find myself totally in agreement with the Recommendations because of the adoption of the 'modern' model based on the Western cultural values.
Indian society is largely patriarchal and in a segmented society, women of India, cutting across the religion or caste or linguistic lines, do not form a distinct and separate segment. They form a part and parcel of their own communities. That is why their struggle for dignity has to be waged by each segment of them within their own framework. This is the reason why the urban-based, upper class feminism has made little headway in India.
In the Indian context, the women of any deprived social group cannot be better off than its men. Nor can the women of a marginalised minority group be better off than the average women of the country as a whole.
Every human group has its own dynamics of change though it is continuously influenced by the overall social environment. Externally induced acceleration of social change can well be counterproductive and self-defeating. It may disintegrate the family and divide the community.
The Muslim Indians form a religious minority. Opposed to religious assimilation or cultural absorption, they aspire to maintain their religious identity. The bedrock of this identity is their acceptance of the Holy Quran as the Word of God and of the Sharia, based on the Quran and the Tradition of the Holy Prophet. However, what is immutable is the Quran and not the Fiqh. This leave open for exploration the avenue of reinterpretation (Ijtihad). Social reform to be effective, has to be promoted not in the rejection of the Quran but through its reinterpretation, by going back to the roots I am personally convinced that Islam posits equality between man and woman in every respect, except within the bonds of the family where the husband has the final say. That does not mean that polygamy and instant divorce cannot be eliminated and regulated.
I shall not go into factual inaccuracies and misperceptions in the Report. But I would like to comment on some Recommendations:
R1. It can be argued that GOI's reservations on Articles 5A and 16.1 of the CEDAW are indeed in conformity with Article 1.1 of the UN Declaration on Minorities, 1992, which casts a duty on a State to protect the religious identity of minorities.
R2. Reform in Muslim personal law - as distinct from the promulgation of a uniform or common civil code must be consistent with the Quran and the Traditions i.e. within the framework of the Shariah. If the reform ignores this vital consideration it does compromise the religious identity of the Muslim community.
R3. The objective should not be to "overcome patriarchal structure" but to soften their rigidity and make them responsive to forces of change.
R4. There is no reason for the Indian State to introduce/ implement schemes for improving socio-economic status of Muslim women exclusively. All State schemes should and do address disadvantaged women of all communities equally. With the above comments, limited to some of them, I generally endorse the Recommendations.