Indo-Pakistan Joint Statement Nuwara Eliya, 19 March, 1999


 

"The Foreign Minister of Pakistan and the Minister of External Affairs of India reiterated the historic significance of the Lahore Declaration which embodies the vision of the Prime Ministers of the two countries for ending the legacy of tensions and conflicts of the past 50 years and for ushering in a new era of peace, security and prosperity. They discussed ways and means to build on the Lahore Declaration which commits the two countries to build trust and confidence, develop mutually beneficial co- operation and intensify their efforts to resolve all

outstanding issues, including Jammu and Kashmir.

They agreed on the urgency of taking concrete measures for implementation of the Lahore Declaration, the Memorandum of Understanding and the Joint Statement ... In this context, the Ministers agreed that the composite and integrated dialogue process must be intensified.

The Ministers agreed on the following:

i)The meetings of the experts for implementation of the Memorandum of Understanding will he held over the next two months.

ii)The next round of the composite and integrated dialogue process in accordance with the agreed agenda will commence in May 1999 in New Delhi and Islamabad and will be held over a period of six weeks.

(iii)They will meet shortly after the conclusion of ... the composite and integrated dialogue process.

iv)The committee on humanitarian issues ... set up by the Prime Ministers at the Lahore Summit will meet in April 1999 to formalise the agreement on the issue of release of civilian prisoners as well as to discuss other humanitarian issues.

v)Both sides having agreed to relax the visa regime for several categories of visitors, the specific measures shall be announced by the two Governments shortly.

(vi) Delegations of experts from India shall visit Pakistan during April 1999 for identifying areas of cooperation in information technology, Y2K and WTO-related issues. (Source: The Hindu, 20 March, 1999)

Pakistani Journalist Irfan Husain in the Dawn, Karachi

.. For any progress to be made in Indo-Pak relations, we will have to delink Kashmir from other elements. Trade, travel and tourism must be opened up ... It is not India which is being penalised by our Kashmir-first stance; our confrontationist policies are costing us much more ... Irrespective of the rights and wrongs of the unending debate on Kashmir, we have to face the reality of the Indian occupation of a large part of the State while we occupy another. The situation is not going to change.

So, instead of keeping up the plebiscite drumbeat the world is deaf to, we might as well get on with things rather than rant on about the injustices of history and geography ... Obviously, there will be considerable resistance from the large number of ostriches who inhabit this country. But the Nawaz Sharif Government with its huge Parliamentary majority can push the deal through".

"And while we keep trotting out the well-worn UN resolutions calling for a plebiscite to determine the will of the Kashmiri people, we conveniently forget that the same resolutions called for a complete withdrawal of Pakistani forces from all parts of the State as a precondition to the vote. We never fulfilled this condition, thus giving the Indians an excuse to back out of their commitment. Subsequently, India made the contested state a part of the Union, thus making the UN resolutions null and void ...The Indians are not going to hand us their bit of Kashmir on a platter, and we have neither the military might nor the international support needed to change the status quo in our favour. Sooner or later, there will be an agreementdividing the state along the present Line of Control. Reaching this understanding sooner rather than later will save us a lot of money and a lot of frustration ... The Nawaz Sharif government with its huge parliamentary majority can push the deal through" .. (Source: Inder Jit in The Hindustan Times, 16 March, 1999)

Muchkund Dubey On Fruits of Lahore Summit

The Lahore summit was no doubt a symbolic event. But history is full of examples of symbolic gestures having acquired their own momentum and swept aside years of misunderstanding, bitterness and conflicts. For all one knows, forces released by the Lahore spirit may overwhelm the political leadership, military establishment and bureaucracy of the two countries, making it difficult for them later to prevent their people from coming together ...

One can understand Pakistan's desire to link progress on other issues with that on Kashmir. Its bottomline is not to allow this issue to be relegated to the background. But for achieving this purpose, Pakistan must know what to link and what not to link, when to link and how far to go

on linking. For example, there is no point in linking the Kashmir issue with nuclear CBMs ... Besides, it is counterproductive to link Kashmir with issues such as Siachen, Tulbul, and Sir Creek the resolution of which constitutes a positive-sum game and a stalemate over which involves tremendous opportunity costs for both the countries.

It is of supreme importance to maintain the momentum of the dialogue initiated in Lahore. This above all calls for a national consensus in both the countries ... It will also be necessary to create a solid people's front in support of this new phase of the inter-governmental dialogue. (Source: The Times of India, 25 March, 1999)

Mushirul Hasan on Historiography in Pakistan

An important political statement on the ideological foundation of Pakistan was made by the British archaeologist M Wheeler when he titled his book Five Thousand Years of Pakistan. Likewise, the multi-volume History of the Freedom Movement in Pakistan invented a unified and continuous historical tradition starting with 1707, the year of Aurangzeb's death. Indeed, the intellectual challenge for the Pakistani historians in the 1950s and '60s was to lend historical legitimacy to 'Muslim nationalism' and its fruition in the birth of a Muslim nation. Their task ... was to tell the "remarkable story of their (Muslim) survival and their attainment of sovereign status as the emblem of their freedom."

Historians, some having taught in Indian universities, had to change gears on reaching Pakistan ... rewrite their own histories. They had to construct a different past altogether ...

They had to begin to search for heroes and martyrs, involve new symbols and traditions, and discover milestones, such as the 1857 revolt, for the historical antecedents of Pakistan. In the process, were pressed into service, Shaikh Ahmad Sirhindi, Shah Waliullah and Syed Ahmad Barelwi ... In their relentless search the Pakistani historians also turned to Syed Ahmad Khan

(and) traced the 'two-nation' theory to some of his utterances.

The issue was not just the defence of Partition ... but a different reading of the past involving, among other things, the rejection of a diverse but vibrant composite cultural and intellectual legacy. The legitimation of a Muslim homeland required, first of all, the image of the Muslims as a monolithic entity, acting in unison and committed to specifically Islamic values and norms.

Second, it was necessary to portray them as a beleaguered community.

... At the heart of it is the tendency to demonise the Hindus, more than the British, and to attribute Muslim social and educational backwardness to the unremitting, overwhelming power and prejudice of the Hindus. No salience is attached to nearly two centuries of British rule, to the exploitative nature of colonialism ... This is a misleading and an ahistorical approach. But, then, the mythology of Muslim nationalism has been built on 'Hindu' belligerence and hostility towards the Muslims.

The historian's project has, thus, been to present an image of an always enlightened, largely innocent Muslim community.

The agenda of fellow-historians in India has changed over the decades. Not so in neighbouring Pakistan, where conservative die-hards still base their arguments on the incompatibility of Islam and Hinduism, the cornerstone of Jinnah's two-nation theory. Yet some new, though muted, voices are being heard: the 50th year of Independence have just about given impetus to a re-evaluation of old theories and assumptions.

The historian Ayesha Jalal, based in the US, has charted an independent intellectual trajectory ... A recent book, published by the Oxford University Press in Karachi, introduces a regional dimension to Pakistan's  history. What is lost sight of in the controversy surrounding the two-nation theory, argues its author J. Hussain, "is the basic geographic good sense (sic) of an agricultural nation centred on the great Indus Valley river system." Nowadays, the intellectual ambience has changed. So has the political climate after Zia-ul Haq's death. The intelligentsia continues its search for unity and cohesion in a country torn apart by regional, ethnic and sectarian fissures.

Pakistan's stability and survival as a democracy are and must remain central to our concerns, .. One hopes that frequent contacts and regular interactions would sensitise the people of India and Pakistan to each other's fears and anxieties. The demarcation of boundaries is a settled and irrevocable fact. But borders, as the European experience demonstrates, can also unite. We can build bridges of understanding and live as civilised neighbours ...

My wish is that fellow-historians here and in Pakistan would sit together and revisit the old-fashioned theories on pluralism, and detail the shared traditions that had enabled indus and Muslims to live harmoniously for centuries. Hopefully, someday (we would) bridge the intellectual  gulf that separates the scholarly community in the subcontinent. (Source: The Indian Express, 20 February, 1999)





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives