Ajaz Ashraf on Rising Potential of BSP in UP


 

Caught between the challenge of OBCs at the grassroots, and the demand of Dalits for a share in power, the dilemma upper castes face is: What political decisions should they take to retain their tenuous control over institutions and resources of the state?

.. The struggle for power in the UP BJP is essentially a struggle for ascendancy among upper castes and OBCs, articulated through Kalraj Mishra and Rajnath Singh on the one hand, and Kalyan Singh on the other.

"This aspect is not unique to UP. Throughout the Hindi heartland, upper castes and OBCs are locked in a fierce tussle to establish control over block, bank and tharia – the development, credit and security tripod on which rural India exists - and avenues of employment and patronage in government ..

A combination of Hindutva and what has been called BJP's social engineering - characterised through the appointment of a backward as chief minister under rigid organisational control - enabled upper castes to thwart, if not completely overcome, the challenge from below ..

BJP's social engineering could have worked had it not been for Kalyan's refusal to become a rubber stamp: a leader who could pull in OBC votes and yet refrain from disturbing the delicate socio-political arrangement at the grassroots favouring upper castes. Not only did he refuse to become a puppet, but also demonstrated his relevance to the, party through his tacit support for backward caste consolidation behind Mulayam Singh in this election ...

This apart, three other trends from this general election ought to seriously concern the BJP. For one, both the SP and BSP retained their respective bases - and yet the BJP declined because of depletion in its votes. Second, Muslims are more obsessed abour protection at the grassroots than ushering in a secular, single-party government at the Centre. That they voted for the SP and BSP despite the absence of a Third Front testifies to this.

Third, the media projection of a Congress revival and its eventual accretion of votes was largely at the BJP's expense instead of the SP and BSP's Faced with threats of desertion from both its upper and backward caste supporters, the BJP finds itself in a cleft stick - persistence with or removal of Kalyan will alienate one of the two social groups, and accentuate the grassroots conflict between them. So, what options do upper castes now have in UP? ..

Many political analysts advocate a social alliance of upper castes and Dalits as the contradiction between these two groups is less sharp than what it is between OBCs and upper castes. For one, the relationship between Dalits and upper castes, they argue, has been fashioned over the centuries through traditional mechanisms such as the jajmani system. Second, OBCs as an emerging landowning class have a proportionately smaller resource base than upper castes and are, therefore, more ruthless in exploiting Dalits for better profit margins.

It was for precisely these reasons that the BJP had pushed for an alliance with the BSP two years ago. The BSP-BJP experiment proved to be an abject failure then -and is unlikely to succeed now. Such an alliance will drive away Muslims from the BSP, diminish its independent clout, and render it susceptible to manipulations.

Many believe the Congress' improved performance opens the possibility of resurrecting its formidable alliance of upper caste, Dalits and Muslims ... Upper castes can scarcely be expected to back a party that lacks the potential to muster a majority on its own. Second, Dalits are too enamoured of Mayawati and Kanshi Ram to think of ditching the BSP ..

In the fluid political situation in UP, and with options running out fast, upper castes might have to veer around to the view that the only way of forging a stable and winning alliance is to come together with Muslims and Dalits under the aegis of the BSP. Surprising? It sure is, but the cost benefit analysis of such an arrangement is more favourable for upper castes than an overwhelming OBC victory. Already, during the recent election, Kanshi Ram and Mayawati changed tack, harping on sarvsamaj (entire society) instead of their trademark bahujan samaj. The BSP now plans to launch a jati jodo abhiyan (unite castes campaign) ... (Source: The Hindustan Times, 17 October, 1999)





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives