A.G. Noorani on 'Package Deal' On Junagadh, Hyderabad and Jammu & Kashmir in 1947


 

There is overwhelming evidence to suggest that India was prepared for a package deal on all three in November-December 1947. It was Mohammed Ali Jinnah who turned it down. It was Jinnah's Hyderabad policy which ruined the chances of an agreement ..

In a telegram to the Prime Minister of Pakistan, Liaquat Ali Khan, on November 8, 1947, Jawaharlal Nehru offered: "It is essential, in order to restore good relations between the two Dominions, that there should be acceptance of the principle that, where Ruler of a State does not belong to the community to which the majority of his subjects belong, and where the State has not acceded to that Dominion whose majority community is same as State's, the question whether the State has finally acceded to one or other Dominion should be ascertained by reference to the will of the people".

In his memoirs entitled The Emergence of Pakistan, the then Cabinet Secretary of Pakistan, Mohammed Ali, who became Prime Minister later, revealed: "In one of the discussions between the two Prime Ministers, at which Patel and I were also present, Liaquat Ali Khan dwelt at length on the inconsistency of the Indian stand with regard to Junagadh and Kashmir ... When Liaquat Ali Khan made these incontrovertible points, Patel could not contain himself and burst out: "Why do you compare Junagadh with Kashmir? Talk of Hyderabad and Kashmir and we could reach an agreement". A recent archival disclosure in Pakistan suggest that Liaquat Ali Khan was agreeable but Jinnah was not. As Governor-General he went so far to intrigue against his Prime Minister and get the Cabinet to resolve that no accord with India would be arrived at by the Prime Minister without the Governor-General's approval ... (Source: The Frontline, 21 May, 1999)





Download Whole Month's Document
       

Muslim India Magazine Archives