Disconcerting (stereotype) are here to stay; indeed they are flourishing in Hindi films, television serials and commercials.
And so intrigued is senior bureaucrat Parvez Dewan (Commissioner and Secretary Tourism, J&K) at these projections that for the last twenty years he has been collecting data vis-a-vis the media's portrayal of the various caste and religious groups of the country. His study - which is being compiled into a two-volume book, Cultural Imperialism - is based on 786 Hindi films, 300 television episodes and another 300 commercials ...
Mr. Dewan's findings show that Sikhs are generally portrayed as well-meaning dullards In a great majority of Hindi films, the Christian men are unattractive and invariably clutching a bottle of alcohol. They are also portrayed as petty criminals as against the gang leaders who are almost always Hindi-speaking Aryan Caste Hindus. That presumably signifies power. A Christian man will rarely marry a caste Hindu woman 'and where he does, the marriage will end in disaster. On the other hand, Christian women are projected as fair skinned and generally with loose morals, the smoking, drinking types.
Muslim men are shown in typically 'Muslim' attire. They are either old, handicapped, subordinate, sterile, impotent or homosexual. If they are not any of these, then they are producing too many children. Less than 20 per cent of the Muslim men are portrayed as young but even in this category they are depicted not only as backward but as fundamentalists - mazhab ke pakke, so much so that many of the opening shots start with a Muslim offering namaaz. Another trend being noticed increasingly, since the film Tezaab, is the portrayal of Muslim men as terrorising the local population.
Also in all romantic affairs between a Muslim/ SC/ST/ Christian girl and a caste Hindu boy, it is she who is chasing the boy and not the other way round. On the other hand, some Muslim film producers/directors have portrayed prostitutes and fast women as caste Hindu women ... Some of the Muslim producers/directors like Nadiadwala, Mehboob and K A Abbas have also
portrayed upper caste Hindus as oppressing the lower castes.
Parsis are invariably silly and old. The Chinese settled in India are usually evil and shown as gangsters. Mr. Dewan's findings show that the biased projection is not limited to religious minority groups, but includes the non-Hindi belt. As he says "By and large except for the Hindi-speaking Aryan caste Hindu, nobody seems to have been spared. And even in this category the Kayasthas and Kshatriyas seem the safest.
On the other hand, the depiction of Tamilians in the media is perhaps the worst, for they are not only referred to as idli dosa, but lately they have started to be shown as dons ... Sindhis and Marwaris are again projected along stereotypical lines.
Scheduled Tribe women are depicted as desperate to get the caste Hindu hero. But whilst the ST women are portrayed as clean and forever bathing near river banks, the men are shown as unattractive and dark.
Hyderabadis are invariably portrayed as clowns and made the butt of many a joke. Maharashtrians are either domestics or police inspectors.
Isn't it time these portrayals are seriously examined? A hue and cry is made if there are errors arising from biases in texts but what about the prejudices intrinsic to the visual media?