KASHMIR SITUATION
Harish Khare On Progress Towards Autonomy
The United Front's Common Minimum Programme had promised the people of the State "the maximum degree of autonomy"; now it appears that the installation of a civilian government is deemed to have "solved" the "Kashmir problem".
The absence of any indication of the future direction in the President's address coupled with the National Conference's political courtship with the United Front probably suggests a reluctance to address the autonomy issue. It is not that the Prime Minister and others are not mindful of the entrenched urge in the State for some meaningful autonomy - an urge that remains only partially satisfied with the installation of Dr. Abdullah's Government.
In fact, during his visit last week to the Valley, Mr Deve Gowda had this to tell an audience at Uri: “Whatever may the quantum of autonomy I assure you that your dream about it will come true.
I want you to enjoy the same status which the people in the other parts of the country are enjoying and bring you at par with them. So that you can also live with honour and dignity and the whole Kashmir valley again hums with development".
It is difficult to say whether the above statement was an extempore expression of Mr. Gowda's sentiments or whether it was part of a script. But the statement issued next day in Jammu at the end of the Prime Minister's visit remained conspicuously silent as to how the Kashmiris' "dream" about "autonomy" was to come true.
While it is easy to understand the inability or lack of confidence on the part of the United Front to move forward its agenda on Kashmir, it is difficult to appreciate Dr. Abdullah's compulsion in cosying up to the ruling dispensation in New Delhi, thereby vacating the "nationalist" political space for the Hurriyat and others to occupy.
In fact, on a number of occasions Dr. Abdullah himself had expressed a view that his greatest political mistake was to team up with the Indian National Congress in 1987 (in the so-called Rajiv-Farooq Accord). After that agreement, Dr. Abdullah came to be identified in Kashmiri perception as "an agent of New Delhi "rather than as a champion of the Kashmiri aspirations. Now his all too obvious eagerness to cozy up to the Prime Minister of the day - without any visible compensation for Jammu and Kashmir - betrays an unnatural dependence on "New Delhi".
Dinesh Kumar On Kashmir Problem
Forty-nine years and one day ago, troops of 1 Sikh were airlifted in World War-II vintage Dakotas to fight Pakistani infiltrators who were then on the outskirts of Srinagar airfield.
But the cease-fire was to follow one year, two months and five days later on January 1st, 1949 by which time Pakistani troops had occupied 30,000 square miles of territory altogether amounting to 35 per cent of the J&K state. By then again, the Indian Army had lost 1,103 soldiers of which 1,022 were infantrymen.
Sixteen years later, Pakistan launched its infamous Operation Gibraltar in which about 5,000 Pakistani soldiers and tribesmen infiltrated the Valley to carry out subversive activities. The Army lost another 3,263 soldiers of which once again 2,585 were infantrymen ... But today India has been fighting a far more deadly form of warfare - a "low-intensity" proxy war. It has been a low-cost, no-loss option for Pakistan, but it has imposed a horrendous toll on the security forces and civilian population of India. To begin with, the Army has lost more soldiers in the last seven years in counter-insurgency operations than it did during the 1947-48 war.
Statistics given by the Infantry directorate put the figure of army men lost in internal security duties in Kashmir and Punjab at 1,177 which is more than the 1947-48 war figure of 1,103. Another 524 soldiers have died fighting in the Siachen glacier in the upper J&K region which for the last 12 years has remained the world's highest, coldest and most expensive battlefield.
Put together, the figure works out at 1,701 soldiers killed till September 8 this year. But figures tabled in Parliament on July 24 1996, put the figure of armymen killed in J&K alone since 1988 - slightly higher at 1,769 - including 118 officers and 133 Junior Commissioned Officer (JCOs). Either figure works out to more than the number of soldiers killed in the 1947-48 war. In addition here is an even larger number of wounded and maimed soldiers.
A No-War-No-Peace (NWNP) situation continues along the Line of Control (LC) in J&K perhaps making it the only such region of its kind in the world. The monthly average of incidents of exchanges along the total 1,225-kilometer J&K stretch of the LC/international border would easily reach 400 a month.
The proxy war continues to leave behind it a long trail of death and destruction Between 1988 and January 1996 alone, the total number of people killed by militants in Kashmir works out to 13,013. In addition, over 7,000-odd militants including about 400 foreign mercenaries mostly from Afghanistan have been killed, taking the death figures to well over 20,000. Close to 25,000 militants have been caught while another 2,500 have surrendered. The weapons confiscated are enough to arm more than one Infantry division.
Civilian property destroyed including, till January, 1996, 686 educational institutions, six hospitals, 8468 private houses, 337 bridges, 1162 shops and 1,206 government buildings in over a total of 4,018 incidents. The wages of fighting a low-intensity conflict situation has been much more than fighting a conventional war.
Riyaz Punjabi on Kashmir Situation
The Opposition parties in Kashmir are once again raising the pitch of the demand for the right of self-determination. The effort is obviously directed to make this demand a focal point of their activities.
The Hurriyat has the democratic right to protest against human rights violations in Kashmir. In fact, prominent human rights groups and activists joined the protest march to express their solidarity with the Hurriyat leaders in the cause of the protection of human rights. However, its insistence on the right of self-determination as a solution to the conflict needs elaboration.
The Hurriyat has been vacillating between the approaches of the right of self-determination and a tripartite dialogue among India, Pakistan and the people of Kashmir, in seeking a solution to the conflict. In fact, the demand for the right of self-determination has been voiced intermittently by a section of Kashmiri leadership in the last four decades. The ambiguity of the term and its usage out of historical context have led to a great deal of confusion which has been responsible for distorting the psyche of an entire generation in J&K. In a way, the ongoing turmoil in the State may be related to this distorted perception, particularly among the younger generation.
In the historical context, the Kashmir "struggle for freedom" cantered round the twin-demand of abolition of the feudal order and transfer of power from the autocracy of the Maharajah to the people. These demands were incorporated in a resolution expressed in terms of the right of self-determination. In fact, this resolution was initiated by the then communist leadership with the support of the leaders of the Indian National Congress (NC) led by Jawaharlal Nehru during the Sopore Convention of the NC in 1944. These national leaders had gone to Kashmir to express their solidarity with the people in their struggle against the feudal, autocratic rule of the Maharajah. In the universal context, under those historical circumstances, the right of self-determination was demanded by oppressed nationalities and peoples against alien and colonial dominations. These dominations were symbolised by colonial rule the world over.
In the post-colonial era, the right of self-determination acquired a new interpretation and has since been used in an entirely different context. The substance of the right came to be recognised in the form of establishing democratic institutions which would guarantee the right of self- governance to the people. The concept of self-determination had to be crucially adjusted to multi-cultural and pluri-religious societies. Thus, in the realm of international law and constitutional jurisprudence, it was increasingly realised that the exercise of the right of self-determination could not be stretched to a point leading to the dismemberment of states. The UN Commission on Human Rights, perceived to be the custodian of such rights, excluding the right to secede, concluded that the right of self-determination entailed the right of ethno-cultural groups to self-governance at the local levels as well as their representation in their national governments.
After the accession of the J&K State to the Indian Union in 1947, a Constituent Assembly was elected in J&K to draft a Constitution for the State. Addressing the Constituent Assembly Sheikh Abdullah said, "We are exercising the right of self-determination (through this Constituent Assembly)". The institution of landlords was abolished and the ownership of land was given to the tiller.
Second the hereditary rule of the Maharajah was abolished and the right of governance was transferred to the people. Thus, both these developments completed the process of empowering the people economically and politically, which is the essence of the right of self-determination. Sheikh Abdullah repeatedly asserted that his "quarrel with the Union of India basically arose over the quantum of autonomy, and the accession between the State and the Union was never in question." The Sheikh, whose party, NC, represented the vast majority of people in the State, was bargaining hard for greater constitutional powers. However, the Union of India was not prepared to go beyond certain limits in this behalf. It may be emphasised that this type of bargaining is a common feature of a federal polity where there is always a tussle between the Union and the units over sharing political power and partaking of the national resources. However, communalisation of the atmosphere in J&K created a great deal of misgivings in the minds of the nation and it equally led to the estrangement of the people in Kashmir. The demand for the right of self-determination became the plank of Sheikh Abdullah's politics after his Government was dismissed in 1953 and he was incarcerated. However, he made it repeatedly clear, and it can be verified from his autobiography Aatish-i-Chinar, that he raised the demand of self-determination solely in the context of more federal powers for the State ... The demand for greater autonomy is not confined to J&K. More and more States are joining the debate seeking more powers for themselves. There is an overall wave for federalising the Indian political system.
The Hurriyat's interpretation of the right of self-determination, apart from misleading the people, has essentially the potential for dismemberment of the Indian republic. The Hurriyat has known that this position has no international support. Even the United States has rejected this interpretation. It is now universally recognised that the road to conflict resolution leads through electoral and democratic processes.
History has offered an opportunity to the Hurriyat to set a new agenda for the people of Kashmir. It needs to realise that opportunities of self-governance through parliamentary methods are the. Culmination of the struggle for self-determination. It can create a space for itself by playing the role of a healthy Opposition in the State. It may support the demand for greater autonomy and redeem the people from death and devastation experienced in the last seven years of militancy and turmoil.
Pushp Saraf on Farooq Abdullah's Problems
Farooq Abdullah, along with his ministers and National Conference legislators, has mostly functioned from the winter capital of Jammu. All of them have been exposed to the charge of neglecting the Valley since then. True or false, the popular perception is that the NC lcaders have left their close associates, who worked for their victory in the face of heavy odds, at the mercy of militants. Hardly a week passes without a prominent NC worker being killed in the Valley.
Farooq's problems will perhaps be solved to a large extent if he and his party legislators move around in their constituencies. Of course, this will involve considerable risk to their lives but this is an exercise they must undertake so that their party is able to revive its traditional ties with the local youth. This will also instil courage in the party's rank and file. The NC's failure to reactivate its organisation at the ground level is evident from its inability to effectively counter the multi-party Hurriyat. Which continues to enforce bandhs as and when it likes.
Apparently as a strategy to regain popular support, Farooq is relying on former militants.
It is necessary that Farooq ensures that while winning over new allies, he does not lose the support of those who have stood by him in difficult times Farooq's presence has begun to generate the badly-needed political activity in the State. In a belated move, the Hurriyat has set up a unit in Jammu Obviously the purpose is to counter NC's reach and influence in the region.
Farooq should welcome Hurriyat's bid to expand its base, as the vindication of his own stand to promote democratic fervour and regional harmony in the State.
Government Statement On Actual Line of Control in J&K
The position of the Government is that the whole of the State of J&K, including the area under illegal occupation of Pakistan, and portions of the State illegally ceded by Pakistan, is an integral part of India Resolutions were passed by both Houses of Parliament on 22 February, 1994, in which inter alia, this was reiterated, and it had been stated that Pakistan should vacate the areas of the Indian State of J&K which they have occupied through aggression. Government are aware of statements, purportedly made by the Chief Minister of J&K that the Line of Control should be converted into International Border leaving Pakistan occupied areas of the State in the hands of Pakistan. However, the Government remains firm on the position as stated above.
APHC: Mirwaiz Omer Farooq's Views
The movement is for justice and people's right to decide their future. The Government of India has tried to portray us as a terrorist and Islamic movement. The APHC believes in peace and is for resolution of the Kashmir problem peacefully.
The election was a referendum against Farooq Abdullah. Only 10 per cent participated in the polls. The entire exercise was a military exercise. It had to be done in a phased manner since Indian troops were not in sufficient number.
Gun and ammunition are not our only strength, we have tremendous public support.
Situation has worsened after the elections. There has been more violence; Government of India has an upper hand in Kashmir. The Army, troops, paramilitary forces, TADA, PSA (Public Safety Act) prevail in Kashmir. Civil administration is nowhere in picture.
Sticking to the UN resolution was not proving conducive for any breakthrough on Kashmir That means Kashmiris either choose India or Pakistan. So there was no scope for a dialogue. So this time we expect India to respond seriously. The time is right for the Government of India to start a dialogue with Pakistan and at the same time with Kashmiri people.
An election under a neutral body like the United Nations be held to elect the representatives of Kashmiris for holding dialogue with the Centre.
We are not against India 'and Pakistan having better economic relations, after all there is so much poverty in both the countries. Kashmiris want to become a bridge between these two countries. If it comes to a clash of interests with Pakistan over Azad Kashmir's future, we will have to face it.
APHC came into being on an agreement on certain basis among its nearly 32 constituent groups. It took us some time to come to an agreement for broadening our political base. We want to dispel the theory that ours is a religious movement. We are striving for a political resolution and for that we have to seek ideas and opinions of people of the entire Jammu and Kashmir state and even from northern areas (Pakistan) and Chitral. We have just begun with opening our provincial unit in Jammu with the inclusion of non-Muslims. We are opposed to the idea of bifurcating Jammu and Kashmir on religious grounds.
We want all migrants back, but we can't do it unless we feel they can return to their homes. The government can put them into specially guarded cantonments, but that is not the answer. We must strive for people-to-people contact for bringing migrants back to Kashmir. Kashmiri pandits are part of Kashmir.